Unpacking the hidden costs: the true price of white pallet exchange

written by IFCO SYSTEMS, 26th september 2024, in Stories

Beyond the surface: why perfect information is crucial for smart business decisions

Imagine you’re considering purchasing a new piece of hardware, like a high-end printer. The initial cost seems reasonable, and it promises excellent performance. But after you’ve made the purchase and committed, the surprises start rolling in: costly ink subscriptions, regular maintenance fees, and unexpected repairs. Suddenly, what seemed like a bargain quickly turns into a financial burden, and by the time you discover these hidden expenses, it’s too late to go back. The lack of transparency from the start leaves you regretting a decision that seemed smart at first.

In the business world, particularly in supply chain logistics, having complete information from the outset is critical. White pallet exchange can often appear to be the most cost-effective solution. You buy them once and assume they will serve you for years. But without understanding the hidden costs, you risk making decisions that hurt your bottom line. To fully compare different pallet management systems, we must look at the Total Cost of Ownership (TCO), which involves evaluating the entire lifecycle of pallets – or, simply put, their journey through the supply chain. Let’s dive in and uncover the hidden costs behind the seemingly economical facade of white pallet exchange.

White pallet hidden costs

Various models of white pallet exchange

But what about white pallet exchange, which often appears to be the most cost-effective option? On the surface, buying and reusing pallets seems like a straightforward, long-term solution. Yet, white pallet exchange happens in various ways, typically guided by loosely established conventions regarding "what needs to be done" – from pallet quality to custody responsibilities and managing pallet vouchers.

What’s often overlooked is how risky it is to base your supply chain on such uncertain practices. This became painfully clear during the 2021 collapse of packaging wood supply, when soaring prices and widespread shortages brought the issue of pallets directly to the CEO level.

Let’s take a closer look at some of the most common pallet exchange options available on the global market today.

EPAL (European Pallet Association) pallets

EPAL wooden pallets are exchanged based on established conventions. While they perform well when new, the costs of distinguishing them from similar wooden alternatives, maintaining their quality, and managing exchanges can add up, making them less cost-effective over time.

Voucher exchange

This system relies on vouchers to track pallet exchanges between suppliers and retailers. While intended to simplify the process, market experience shows that redeeming vouchers can be cumbersome, especially during peak seasons. Additionally, the administrative burden and the risk of expired or lost vouchers often lead to unexpected costs, complicating what initially appears to be a straightforward solution.

Same-time exchange

A system based on the physical exchange of pallets at the point where goods are transferred between parties may seem straightforward, but it introduces significant complexities. With no long-term agreements in place, the quality of pallets becomes unpredictable, often varying based on available stock.

More importantly, the unsustainable transport costs – moving only a couple of stacks of pallets instead of a full load of goods – add unnecessary expenses and increase carbon emissions.

Logistics companies also bear the burden of adapting their operations to manage these pallet exchanges on behalf of their customers, ensuring they don’t lose money in the process. This added complexity creates inefficiencies throughout the supply chain, and as we know, complexity is cost.

One-way pallets

In this linear model, pallets are used once and then either discarded or sold, eliminating the need for returns and exchanges. While it may simplify logistics, this approach results in higher waste and environmental costs, as well as increased expenses for continuous pallet purchases.

The true price of white pallet exchange: what are the hidden costs?

Before deciding on the best pallet solution for your business, it’s crucial to recognize that the apparent savings of white pallet exchange come with hidden expenses. While the initial costs may seem straightforward, there are numerous concealed costs that can significantly impact your overall budget. To make informed decisions, it’s essential to understand the full financial picture.

A closer look at the cost breakdown

The costs associated with white pallet exchange can be categorized into both visible and hidden expenses, with many additional costs often overlooked. This analysis is grounded in comprehensive industry research and decades of expertise from leading professionals in pallet pooling. Drawing on real-world data, it becomes clear that the financial impact of white pallet exchange extends far beyond the surface, revealing a much more complex and costly reality.

Known costs:

  • Purchase (29%): This is the most visible and straightforward expense, representing the initial investment required to acquire pallets. However, maintaining an adequate stock demands continuous spending as pallets wear out and need replacement over time.

Hidden costs:

  • Transport (35%): Usually the largest hidden cost, this covers the expenses involved in returning empty pallets. These costs can quickly accumulate, especially over long distances and frequent trips, quietly eating away at your bottom line.
  • Eco Tax (7%): This cost, which varies by country, reflects the environmental taxes associated with pallet disposal. As regulations tighten, this expense is likely to rise, further impacting your overall costs.
  • Capital Expenditure (Capex) (4%): Although it represents a smaller percentage, Capex costs are related to the acquisition of proprietary assets rather than rental or pooling services. These costs encompass long-term investments in pallet management infrastructure, including specialized storage systems and advanced tracking technology, which are essential for efficient operations.
  • Administrative Costs (13%): Managing the extensive administrative tasks associated with pallet exchanges – such as documentation, tracking, coordination, invoicing, and reporting – consumes significant time and resources. Beyond these tasks, the process of retrieving pallets from distant warehouse locations, sorting them by quality, and handling the actual exchange is highly unproductive. Discussions often shift towards issues like exchange balances, load rejections, and pallet quality, turning what should be a straightforward process into a time-consuming part of negotiations between sales managers and buyers.
  • Inspection, Repairs, Handling, and Scrap (12%): White exchange pallets are notorious for their fragility, leading to frequent damages that require regular inspection and maintenance. These processes come with significant costs. When pallets are beyond repair, they must be scrapped, adding another layer of expense along with the resources required for disposal. Additionally, the environmental implications of disposing of damaged pallets can further contribute to your overall costs.

Additional costs to consider:

  • Storage expenses: Every unused pallet taking up space in your warehouse represents a hidden cost. Storage isn’t free, and managing a surplus inventory of dormant pallets can drain both spatial and financial resources.
  • Loss and theft: White pallets are prone to loss and theft, and the cost of replacing missing pallets can add up quickly. Keeping track of these losses and their financial impact is essential for accurate budgeting.
  • Legal and compliance issues: Adhering to local and international regulations, such as ISPM-15 standards for pallet treatment, incurs additional costs. Legal disputes over pallet exchanges can also lead to unforeseen expenses, making compliance a critical consideration.
  • Food safety vulnerabilities can lead to substantial costs, including additional expenses for primary and secondary packaging, film, and banding, as well as potential product loss and food waste. Shipping produce on wooden pallets often requires food-related certifications in various regions, adding layers of bureaucracy and increasing administrative costs. Moreover, poor-quality pallets can cause damage and spoilage, resulting in entire loads being scrapped. Since the quality of pallets in an exchange system is never guaranteed, this uncertainty can lead to higher costs, safety concerns, and unnecessary food waste.

The breakdown above highlights that the majority of expenses (71%) are hidden, often overlooked in initial calculations. Recognizing and understanding these costs is essential for making informed decisions regarding pallet management strategies.

Real-world impact: the cost of inefficiencies

Consider a company sending 35,000 pallets to market annually but retrieving only 32,000 – a loss of 3,000 pallets each year. The reasons? Retailers keeping pallets for their own use, broken pallets, transport issues, and administrative inefficiencies. The result? Increased costs for purchasing new pallets, additional transport, inspection, and repair expenses. Have you calculated your own pallet attrition rate and its financial impact?

The complexity of the system: a web of inefficiencies

Managing white pallets involves meticulous coordination and a complex web of logistics. Proof of Delivery (POD) documents, various types of vouchers, and the intricate exchange system require constant attention. Manual processes, like handling and returning printed vouchers, create room for errors and inefficiencies. Is your current system bogged down by paperwork and manual handling?

The bigger picture: Total Cost of Ownership (TCO)

To make an informed decision, one must consider the Total Cost of Ownership. It’s not just about the upfront costs of purchasing pallets – it’s about the ongoing expenses of repair, disposal, transportation, storage, administration, and compliance. Are you evaluating the true TCO of your pallet management system?

Transparency of the pooling model

When considering the Total Cost of Ownership (TCO) approach, the pooling model offers several advantages despite its seemingly higher initial expense. Unlike the white pallet exchange system, which can hide various costs, the pooling model provides a transparent pricing structure. This model includes all associated expenses, such as pallet maintenance, management, and compliance, eliminating unexpected costs.

By managing all aspects of pallet logistics, the pooling model ensures a more predictable and straightforward cost structure, ultimately delivering better value and reducing the risk of hidden charges and operational disruptions.

Conclusion: the superiority of the pooling model

The hidden costs of white pallet exchange are numerous and varied, impacting your bottom line in ways that might not be immediately apparent. In contrast, the pooling model offers transparency and cost-effectiveness. With pooling, costs are clear upfront, transforming Capex into Opex and significantly reducing administrative burdens through tech-powered automatic declarations. Moreover, the environmental benefits align with evolving regulations like the PPWR and the broader trend towards eliminating one-way packaging. After considering the full picture, the pooling model not only emerges as the more economical choice but also supports sustainability and operational efficiency in today’s demanding business landscape.

Having good information is the cornerstone of sound decision-making. By understanding and acknowledging all the hidden costs, businesses can navigate the complexities of pallet management and choose a model that truly benefits their operations and the environment.

Don’t let hidden costs erode your bottom line – reach out to our team today to discuss how we can help optimize your pallet management strategy and ensure you’re making the most cost-effective and sustainable choices for your business.

Get in touch!

These articles will also be interesting for you

Sign up now!

Get insights dedicated to the fresh grocery supply chain delivered straight to your inbox. We’re excited to help you navigate the key opportunities in this important industry!

Strinjam se, da mi podjetje IFCO pošilja sporočila in obdeluje moje osebne podatke. Občasno vas želimo kontaktirati, da bi vas obvestili o naših izdelkih in storitvah ter drugi vsebini, ki vas morda zanima. Če se strinjate, označite potrditveno polje. Soglasje lahko kadar koli umaknete. Več informacij o dejanski obdelavi vaših osebnih podatkov si lahko ogledate v našem pravilniku o zasebnosti. *

* Zahtevano polje

followNewsletter
Kako vam lahko danes pomagamo?